Friday, September 25, 2026

World without rocks

 

There's a famous anecdote about Samuel Johnson. It's said that he was so irritated by a mention of George Berkeley's assertion that there is no reality except for what is perceived that he kicked a rock and said, "Thus I refute Berkeley." 

What's the problem with arguing on the internet? Some people think it's that no one respects experts anymore and that leads them to spread misinformation. But in truth, most experts are fatuous idiots and liars, and it's actively a good thing that people ignore them.

A more serious problem is that there's no way to appeal to objective reality. You're not face to face with anyone. You're not sharing space with them. Cyberspace isn't space. So you do see people assert some things and deny other things in a way that would entirely collapse if they weren't alone with their reflections.

2 comments:

susan said...

So it would appear Berkeley didn't believe in objective reality to which Dr. Johnson's reply was to kick a rock. If there is no reality at all, where does that leave us? Are we then unreal, figments of our own non-existent imaginations? It’s enough to make a philosopher's head spin. I wonder if they ever worked it out?

As far as arguing on the internet is concerned, I think George Bernard Shaw said it best: “Never wrestle with pigs. You both get dirty and the pig likes it.”

I love the cartoon you found. Perfect analogy.

Ben said...

Berkeley's philosophy was subjective idealism, holding that (per Wikipedia) "only minds and mental contents exist". To what extent did he disbelieve in the reality of the material universe? It's possible that Dr. Johnson misunderstood. It's even more possible that I'd misunderstand. But you're right, it's definitely the kind of thing that could make your head spin.

There are so many famous quotes that, when you look into them, were never said by the person who was supposed to have said them. But Shaw's line about "Never wrestle with pigs" is genuine, and he is to be congratulated for it.

The cartoon was a lucky find. Felt I needed an illustration.