Tuesday, September 29, 2026

Hey what're the odds

The full title of Joseph Mazur's book Fluke is Fluke: The Math & Myth of Coincidence. The cover of the 2016 Basic Books edition shows a man in silhouette, walking his dog. A lightning bolt descends from the word "Fluke", aimed at the man's head. Wouldn't it be crazy if he had been hit by lightning before and was about to be so struck again?

An excerpt: 

By definition, coincidences are events that happen without apparent cause. Apparent to whom? It does not mean there is no cause. The world generally moves by cause and effect. I say generally, because there are acausal phenomena in physics, psychology, and religion. But the word apparent tells us that the moment we learn the cause of a coincidental phenomenon, its status diminishes to a simple time-space event. That must mean that coincidences are relative to the people affected by them. It also means that the unapparent cause is there, waiting to be discovered. If there is no cause at all, then it happens by chance. 

This is graspable in theory. It doesn't necessarily make this "unapparent cause" easy to pin down. There are probably some coincidences where the actual odds for and against remain a topic of hot debate.

One interesting thing I learned about in this book is the birthday problem, meaning that the probability of two people having the same birthday reaches 50% when there are 23 people in the group. This threw me at first. I would have guessed that this point came at 183, which is about half the number of days in the year. But the numbers check out when you look at it.

2 comments:

susan said...

It sounds like a pretty interesting book considering the premise and explanation. I'm aware our thinking distorts many things into significance that are quite explainable statistically. In general, most coincidences are merely rare circumstances which, given long enough, will occur no matter how improbable the chances were in the first place. It doesn't really affect your life knowing why coincidences and flukes happen but I wonder about the things that mathematics can't explain such as miracles.

In general, people define a miracle as something that is clearly beyond the realm of scientific possiblity. I agree that lots of odd coincidences that are described as miracles really do have common sense explanations as described by Joseph Mazur (he does have an impressive background).

C.S. Lewis argued in his book Miracles that miracles are an interference with nature by a transcendent, supernatural God, rather than a breaking of natural laws. He noted that belief in miracles actually requires a belief in regular, fixed natural laws. You cannot see an exception to a rule unless you first know what the normal rule is.

I always had trouble with that birthday prediction too. I get it but I can't say I've ever been friendly with enough people in one room to see if it's true.

Ben said...

It is an interesting book. I wouldn't say that it's the last word on the subject of coincidences. Well, such a thing probably isn't possible in the first place. There are stories of things happening that seem borderline impossible, but which the odds favor if you look at them closely. For example, a woman who won big on the lottery four times because she kept playing at small amounts until it was her time again. But surely there are events in the world that can't be so easily rationalized, without bending reason itself.

Science today, in terms of the culture of scientific institutions, favors atheism and materialism in a way that it didn't in, say, Sir Isaac Newton's day. Even if it didn't, miracles would be a very difficult thing to study scientifically. One thing that could be considered a miracle is a mild rainfall that happens just in time to keep a fire from getting out of control. Scientists would likely study the two things, fire and rain, separately, possibly obscuring a connection if there is one.

Lewis's definition of miracles is one that makes sense to me. Augustine of Hippo said something very similar, that miracles aren't contrary to nature but reveal nature's hidden power. And it's also true that one must understand the rule before one can perceive the exceptions. All this requires a touch of humility as well.

Walking into a room and asking everybody's birthday isn't something that most of us can do, or at least something we will do. I wonder about ER staff, though. They see everybody's paperwork, so maybe they could confirm.