Sunday, September 27, 2026

Might have beens

There used to be an easy listening station here in the Providence area. It eventually converted to a talk format, but held on through most of the 90s I think. 

Anyway, among the old records they played was "Amapola", sung by Bob Eberly and Helen O'Connell with the Jimmy Dorsey Orchestra. It struck me as a very good performance.

Eberly's story is an interesting one, and for him must have been frustrating. When the Dorsey brothers split up, he stayed with Jimmy's band. Tommy would soon enlist a young Frank Sinatra. So could Eberly have been as big a star as Sinatra, with movie roles and his own record label? Maybe. He had a great voice, as heard here with unavoidable pops and hisses. And he was good looking in a slightly androgynous way. 

It wasn't quite to be, though. Mostly it seems to have come down to timing. When he died in 1981 he'd mostly be remembered by Big Band Era diehards. That's quite a sentence, but there are probably worse fates.

2 comments:

susan said...

Glenn Miller, Benny Goodman, Duke Ellington, Artie Shaw, Louis Prima, Cab Calloway, Les Brown, Harry James, Count Basie, and the Dorsey Brothers were the premier bands of the early to mid-20th century. Theirs was a musical landscape characterized by strong arrangements, powerful brass sections, and irresistible improvisations. Then there were the singers, many of whom became very famous.

There are definitely songs I remember that were sung by Bob Eberly - Tangerine, Green Eyes, Besame Mucho and even the song made ultimately memorable by Terry Gilliam, Brazil. But I didn't remember Bob Eberly himself. He did have a nice voice but I don't think he could have challenged Frank Sinatra or BIng Crosby. Some crooners had that next level of charisma.

It's good that over the course of the years he is still remembered. I have a great fondness for the Swing Era. Thank goodness for Bovi's, eh?

Ben said...

Interesting to note that just about all the musicians you name in the first sentence got their start before World War II. The war itself was a kind of extended hiatus, after which everything changed. Glenn Miller didn't survive to the end of the war, but most of the others lived and worked afterwards, finding the music world alien to their experience. There was the rise of rock 'n' roll, which initially just seemed like rowdy hillbilly music. Also, jazz evolving in a more abstract direction, and people generally looking for different things from popular music. Most found a way to keep going. Prima's profile actually rose quite a bit.

Funny thing about the song "Brazil" is that the version Terry Gilliam featured was by Geoff and Maria Muldaur, both veterans of Jim Kweskin's jug band. With Bob Eberly, it's hard to tell how far he could have gotten on his own. Some singers not quite at the Ol' Blue Eyes level, like Dennis Day, did get noticed by Hollywood.

The big band era produced a lot of great stuff. Bovi's was a special place, and I'm glad I got to see it while it was still there in EP.